← Back to resources
RecoveryFaith

The Difference Between What Was Done to You and What You Did

Allison Brown

After a person or an institution you trusted has hurt you, something happens that I've watched in other people and lived through myself: everything that happened gets poured into one container. What was done to you and what you did get stirred together until you can't tell where one stops and the other starts, and what comes out of the stirring is almost always a single verdict — it was all their fault, or it was all mine. A single verdict is a relief, in its way, because one thing is easier to carry than two true things pointing in opposite directions. It is also overly simplistic, and that wrong simplicity distorts the ability to learn from the experience.

I've written about an ancient sequence that makes healing possible — honest reflection, specific acknowledgment, grief, and a 180-degree turn — in a piece called Sackcloth and Ashes: What I Got Wrong. That sequence only works on one half of what's in the container. You can't repent of something that was done to you, because you didn't do it, and you can't forgive yourself for it either, because you're not the one who owes. So when the two piles get mixed, people end up in one of three places: trying to repent of their own victimization, which is crushing and goes nowhere; skipping the work on their own part because they've decided the whole thing was done to them; or trying to forgive the people who hurt them with steps that were only ever built to address their own wrongdoing, not that of others.

Two Piles, Not One

The first pile is what was done to you: choices other people or systems made that you didn't make and couldn't have prevented by acting differently. The betrayal, the lies told about you, the removal, the control, the cruelty, the silence from the people who were in a position to speak. The test is simple to state and hard to apply when you're hurting: who made the choice? When the answer is someone else, it goes on their ledger, even if you suffered it under pressure, and even if you're furious with yourself for not seeing it sooner. Being deceived isn't the same thing as doing wrong.

The second pile is your own contribution: choices you made, whether or not you were under pressure when you made them. The silence you kept, the thing you protected, the line you let yourself cross, the way you treated people while you were hurting or afraid, the times you defended the institution to someone who was trying to tell you something true. Pressure explains a choice. It doesn't erase it, and it doesn't excuse it, but it doesn't make it unforgivable either. The self-condemnation is the part people are terrified of in this pile, because it's the pile of wrongdoing that lands on you and not on someone else.

Two piles can still sound overly simplistic, and in a way they are, because reality can almost never be reduced to black and white or sorted into clean, exclusive groups. Two is a better count than one, but it's still a simplification. There is grey, and there is overlap, and a single event can hold a thread from each pile braided together. It takes a great deal of honest recollection and reflection to acknowledge all the threads in the tapestry — the good, the bad, and the ugly — and the sorting is only as honest as the looking that comes before it.

Where the Line Falls

One line has to be drawn as plainly as I can draw it, because this is the point where an exercise like this can do real damage. If someone with power over you set the situation up on purpose, treating you as a means to something they wanted — through abuse, coercion, manipulation, a pattern built to keep you quiet or to steer you toward a particular choice — you are not the culpable party, even if you wish you had acted differently. The actions you chose freely are the ones you own. The actions you were set up to make belong to the person who set you up.

That isn't the same as the ordinary pressure I described a moment ago — the fear, the loyalty, the exhaustion, a hard situation you walked into with your eyes open. Pressure like that explains a choice without removing it from you. Being maneuvered is different, and the way to tell them apart is to ask whether you were free to choose something else, or whether the situation had been arranged so that only one choice looked possible. Hindsight makes this harder, because looking back you can see an exit that wasn't visible then, and it feels like you should have taken it. Wishing you had acted differently doesn't make you guilty of how you acted. Where the two are tangled, and they often are, let the person who did the harm carry what they did, and be gentle with yourself about what you did inside of it.

The Exercise

You need two columns, a pen, and about an hour when you won't be interrupted. A few rules before you start. Be specific, the same way acknowledgment has to be specific: not “they treated me badly,” but “I was told in front of the staff that my concerns showed a bad attitude, and I was left off the next three planning calls.” Write one event per line. After each one, ask who made the choice, and put it in the column that answers. And when an item won't sort cleanly, split it into two lines, one in each column, and don't let either one swallow the other.

Prompts to start from

Done to me

What was said about me that wasn't true?

What was taken from me — a role, a reputation, a relationship, a place, a sense of safety?

Who knew what was happening and chose not to act?

What was I told I had to accept?

What did I have no say in?

My own contribution

Where did I stay silent when I knew better?

What did I protect that I should have questioned?

How did I treat people while I was hurting or afraid?

What did I tell myself to make staying easier?

What, specifically, would I do differently now?

A sample, to show the level of detail

Done to me: I was told in a meeting that my questions were a sign of a bad attitude, and I was left off the next three planning calls.

My own contribution: I knew about the budget problem for four months and said nothing, because I told myself it wasn't my area.

Done to me: I was told that leaving would hurt the children we served.

My own contribution: I kept believing that after I'd started having doubts of my own, because believing it was easier than leaving.

The second pair is a split item. The pressure was done to this person, and the decision to keep believing it once their own doubts had started was theirs. Both are true, and each belongs in its own column.

A word about doing this alone: if the left column is heavy, it's worth having someone trained or trusted in the room with you. This is work people were never meant to do in isolation, which is a good part of what the old image of sitting in sackcloth beside a friend is about.

Forgiveness, in Both Directions

Once the two columns exist, forgiveness finally has somewhere to go, because it points a different way for each one.

Forgiving what was done to you

The left column is where you forgive other people, and the best way I know to understand what that means is the language Jesus uses for it: “forgive us our debts,” as most English translations put it, and the word is a financial one. A debt is something owed. Forgiving someone is releasing a debt they owe you, which means the debt has to be real before it can be released. That's why this can't start with a decision to forgive. It starts with the list you just wrote, because you can't release what you've never itemized.

What forgiveness leaves out matters just as much, and it's where most of the harm in this subject gets done. It doesn't require reconciling with the person or trusting them again. It doesn't excuse what they did, or decide it wasn't that bad, or hurry you toward the point where it stops hurting. It doesn't wait for them to be sorry, and no one else gets to set its deadline. A person can release a debt and never be in a room with the one who owed it.

It also can't skip the mourning. The sequence from the other piece applies here too, and this column is where most of the grief lives — for what was lost, for what you believed about the people involved, for the years invested. A forgiveness announced before that grief has happened is willpower in a costume, the same as anywhere else. In my experience, people who do this honestly find they have to release the same debt more than once, through different seasons, because it keeps turning up in new places, and that isn't failure. It's what letting go of something that large actually looks like.

Forgiving yourself for what you did

The right column is where you receive forgiveness and, eventually, give it to yourself, and the order matters more here than anywhere else in this piece. Self-forgiveness comes after the sequence — after the honest reflection, the specific acknowledgment, the grief, and the turning — and never in place of them. Said early, “I forgive myself” is an amnesty you've granted yourself so you can stop feeling something, which is the same shortcut as treating grace as permission to skip the looking. Said at the end of the work, it means something different, because now you know what you're being forgiven for, and that makes the mercy accurate instead of general.

I also believe, as a Christian, that you're receiving this more than manufacturing it. The debt in the right column has already been paid by someone else, and the work is agreeing with that verdict instead of continuing to demand payment from yourself. Refusing to receive it after you've done the work can look like humility, but it works more like pride, because it insists your debt is bigger than the payment that was already made. After a real accounting, there comes a point where continuing to punish yourself has stopped being repentance and become a refusal to finish and move forward.

Where you can make something right with the people you affected, and it's safe and welcome to try, do it — that belongs to the turning. Your own forgiveness can't depend on how they respond, though, because some of them won't answer and some shouldn't be contacted at all.

Set side by side, the two directions have more in common than their difference suggests. Both are debt language, and neither is cheap. Both depend on the same earlier act, which is the truth-telling the exercise exists to produce: you can't release a debt you've never itemized, and you can't receive release for one you've never looked at. And both take longer than anyone wants them to. People who skip the itemizing end up with forgiveness that's really avoidance, whichever direction it points.

If you do the exercise this week, don't expect to finish it in an afternoon. In my experience, people come back to their two columns over seasons, adding lines they weren't ready to see the first time, moving a few from one side to the other as they understand more, and finding that the work gets lighter as the list gets truer. Do it with someone you trust if you can. The columns exist so that you can carry what is actually yours and set down what never was.

There's more to say about all of this than one person can tell — how to release a debt when the person isn't sorry, how to approach the right-hand column when the people you affected aren't safe to contact, what to do when forgiveness doesn't feel like anything at all. This is wisdom that belongs to humanity collectively, and it has always been bigger than what one post, or many posts from one writer, could hold. I'm not claiming to know something no one has ever lived or heard before. People came to this long before me, people are coming to it alongside me, and people will come to it after, each in their own way and in their own time, and I'd rather offer what I've seen in the humility that belongs to that company. I intend to share both the wisdom and the folly of how this often plays out, for better or for worse, with the aim always of learning a better way, and with the hope that some of it spares someone from having to learn it by making the same mistakes firsthand.

Work with Un-barred

The lost thing is sought because of its inherent value.

Explore services