← Back to resources
RecoveryFaith

Sackcloth and Ashes: What I Got Wrong

Allison Brown

I'm learning to live more of my life in community these days — which means more of my life gets shared with others, and more of theirs gets shared with me, messier and closer than it used to be. Over the last several years, that's made me more and more intrigued with the practice of mourning, specifically the biblical image of sackcloth and ashes — people tearing their clothes, putting on coarse, uncomfortable cloth, sitting in dust and dirt, sometimes for days. I used to read those passages as just ancient drama, the Bronze Age version of wailing. I don't read them that way anymore. I think they're describing a sequence, a very specific one — and I think it's exactly the kind of thing community either makes possible or makes impossible, depending on whether the people around you still know how to do it. I think we've mostly lost it. And I think losing it is costing people the actual healing they're looking for.

The Sequence, and Which Parts Are Feelings

Self-reflection, acknowledgment, mourning, repentance — I used to lump all four of those together as “processing it,” some vague emotional weather you sit through. They're not the same kind of thing at all, and I think that's exactly the point. Three of the four are cognitive work. Only one of them is a feeling. And each one does something the others can't, which means skipping any single one of them costs you something specific.

Self-reflection comes first, and it's harder than it sounds, because it's the work of actually looking at your own behavior and your own motives, honestly, without flinching away from the parts that implicate you. This is where most people quietly bail, because the instinct the moment something starts to look like your fault is to reach for context, for the other person's worse behavior, for the pressure you were under — anything that lets you off the hook before you've actually looked at what happened. Skip this stage and everything after it is an insipid, washed-out retracing instead of a fact. You can't acknowledge, grieve, or repent of something you were never willing to actually examine.

Acknowledgment is cognitive too, but it's a different kind of work than reflection, because it requires putting what you found into specific words — out loud, or on paper, to someone other than just yourself. Not “I wasn't at my best.” That's a character verdict, vague enough that it can't be argued with and specific enough about nothing that it doesn't require you to change anything. What acknowledgment actually requires is naming the specific behavior, the specific choice, the thing you actually did, at a particular time, in a particular room: I did this. That specificity is the whole point — it's the only kind of statement precise enough to actually be acted on. This is the stage people most often fake, substituting a vague, generous version of events for the specific one, because the specific one is so much harder to live with. Skip it, or soften it, and the private reflection you did has a way of quietly re-editing itself over time, into a kinder story than what actually happened. Acknowledgment names the truth and keeps it from drifting.

Mourning is the only one of the four that's actually a feeling, and it's the stage our culture is worst at tolerating, in ourselves or in anyone else. It's the real grief over what reflection and acknowledgment just made you look at — allowed to be grief, slow and uncomfortable, instead of rushed past on the way to fixing something. Skip this one and whatever resolution follows is just willpower wearing the costume of change, and willpower is notoriously bad at outlasting a hard week, a bad month, or the first real test of the old pattern. I've watched that kind of change not hold, in my life, and in the lives of others, more than once, because it was decided instead of felt.

Repentance comes last, and it's cognitive again: a real turning, a decision followed by an actual, sustained change in behavior — not a feeling of being sorry that fades by Thursday. This is the stage that proves whether the first three were real. You can reflect honestly, acknowledge specifically, and grieve fully, and still walk back into the same room and make the same choice under the same pressure, if the turning never actually happened. Skip repentance and you're left with excellent insight and real tears and no actual difference in what you do next time — which, from where anyone else is standing, looks exactly like nothing changed at all.

Why We Don't Do This Anymore

Our culture doesn't have much appetite for self-reflection, and when it does make room for it, the room usually gets used for blame-shifting instead — pointing at the system, the context, the other person's worse behavior, anything that lets the self stay blameless. There's something close to idolatry in how hard we protect that blamelessness, both personally and institutionally. A person will defend their own innocence more fiercely than almost anything else they believe. So will a board. So will a whole organization.

Part of what makes this so hard, I think, is that we want so badly to already be our aspirational self — the fully healed, fully whole version we yearn for — that we resist anything that shows us the actual self, the one still in process, imperfect, with real work left to do. But that's exactly what this sequence is. Self-reflection is a mirror, not a punishment, and it's only unbearable because it tells the truth about the gap between who you are and who you're still becoming. I don't think it's possible to close that gap without first being willing to see it for what it is.

There's a specific, Christian-flavored version of this same avoidance, and it deserves its own name. Our culture of mercy and grace — which is real, and good, and exactly what's promised — gets quietly repurposed sometimes into permission to skip the examination altogether. If grace already covers it, why go looking for it? That gets the order backwards, though. It's only after you've actually examined something closely — named it specifically, let yourself see the real distance between who you are and who you're meant to become — that you become accurately aware of how much mercy you actually need, instead of a vague, general sense that you probably need some. Skipping the reflection doesn't make the grace any more real. It just means you're receiving mercy for a version of the wrong you never let yourself fully see. And yes, that closer look is exactly where shame and disappointment tend to show up, which is a real downer, and nobody volunteers for it. But shame you've actually looked at and can name is different from shame you've only ever avoided — one of those eventually lets go of you. The other one doesn't, because it was never examined, just outrun.

What This Looks Like in Practice

I think about a man I'll describe only in outline, because the shape of this is common enough that it doesn't need a name attached. He'd spent years in a leadership role inside an organization he loved, and when hard questions started surfacing about how things were being run, he stayed quiet — not out of malice, just out of loyalty, and fear, and the belief that raising his hand would do more damage than good. Years later, after the organization went through exactly the reckoning his silence had helped delay, he could tell you precisely what he should have said and when. He could acknowledge it, clearly, in a single sentence. What he hadn't done, even years on, was actually grieve it — sit with what his silence had cost other people, let that be sorrow instead of just an accurate sentence he'd gotten good at saying. The acknowledgment had calcified into a story he told. It had never become repentance, because it had never passed through grief.

I think about a woman, in an entirely different setting, who sat in guilt for years over a decision she'd made in a moment of real fear — guilt so constant it had become part of her identity, something she brought up unprompted, almost as a credential. What she'd never done was the earlier, harder cognitive work: specifically naming what she'd actually done. She was drowning in the one felt stage of this sequence and had never done the other three. The feeling was real. It wasn't repentance. It was the purgatory of unfinished business.

Not every example is a cautionary one, though, and it's worth ending here instead of on two failures. There's a whole subculture that never stopped doing this on purpose, continuously, without treating any step of it as optional or as something you finish once and move past — recovery communities, Alcoholics Anonymous chief among them, where self-examination, honest acknowledgment, real grief over the wreckage, and a decision followed by changed behavior aren't a one-time event. They're a practice, repeated, for life, and a real shout-out is owed to every person who's ever sat in one of those rooms and done this work in front of other people. I don't think it's an accident that one of the only corners of modern culture still doing ancient sackcloth-and-ashes work, in substance if not in name, is also one of the only corners that reliably produces real, lasting change in people. Other models built on the same principle keep showing up, too, which I find genuinely encouraging — Celebrate Recovery, running in churches all over the country, is one. The method works. We've just mostly confined it to rooms where people have already lost everything else, instead of treating it as something anyone could use before it gets to that point.

The Part Where You Take It Off

Here's what I love most about the actual biblical picture, and what I think gets lost completely when we talk about this as just “sitting with your feelings.” Sackcloth and ashes was never only a private act. In the book of Job, when his three friends hear what's happened to him, they travel to him, and when they see him they weep, tear their own clothes, and sit on the ground with him for seven days and seven nights without saying a word — not fixing anything, not offering advice, just present, in the dirt, because his suffering was too large for speech. I love that. I love that grief like this was something you could join someone in, on purpose, as an act of friendship — not because you'd done anything wrong yourself, but because someone you loved was wrestling with hard stuff and shouldn't have to do it alone.

And it was never meant to be permanent. The Psalms are full of the other half of this — the half our culture skips to without earning, usually, but which is just as real and just as necessary in its own time. “You have loosed my sackcloth and clothed me with gladness,” one psalm says, describing God turning mourning into dancing. The sackcloth comes off. The ashes get washed away. There's a day you get up off the ground and rejoin your life — not because the grief wasn't real, but because grief that never ends isn't holiness, it's a different way of staying stuck.

That's the whole sequence, as I understand it now: reflect honestly, acknowledge specifically, grieve fully, turn and change — and then, when it's actually time, get up, take off the sackcloth, and go. Skipping any one of those steps doesn't make you more spiritual, or more disciplined, or somehow exempt from the work. It means the work doesn't get finished — and unfinished work like this doesn't just sit there quietly waiting for you to get back to it. It resurfaces. Usually in a new setting, with new people who don't yet know what you're capable of, often at a point when you're more trusted and more senior than you were the first time — which means the cost is higher the second time around, not lower. The debt doesn't go away because you stopped looking at it. It compounds, and it waits for the next room you walk into.

I admonish myself to take the time this actually asks for — to do the work, slowly, without shortcuts, on my own and with those I trust. I share this with you in the same spirit: it is in everyone's best interest to seek truth, however hard it is to look at, and learn from it, rather than to ignore it, suffer, and pay the same debt twice.

Work with Un-barred

The lost thing is sought because of its inherent value.

Explore services