Who Holds Up a Toxic Leader? The Army Nobody Talks About
Allison Brown
Almost everyone in my circle was talking about it for a few weeks there — a documentary about a charismatic, dysfunctional leader, years of damage, an institution that protected him long after anyone paying attention should have known better. And everyone had strong feelings, but they went one of two places: horror and fascination with the villain, or grief and anger on behalf of the victims. Both real. Both understandable. Both getting plenty of airtime. What nobody seemed to give any real thought to was the army of people who enabled him — the board that looked away, the staff who knew and said nothing, the whole apparatus that let it run for years. That's the part I can't stop thinking about.
The Ones Nobody Writes About
The villain gets attention because he's the actual monster of the story — easy to hate, impossible to look away from, the kind of person you can spend hours picking apart trying to figure out what makes someone like that. The victims get attention because their pain is real and visible, and it should be honored, and it should never be an afterthought. But the enablers get nothing. Nobody writes the definitive piece about the board member who saw the pattern forming and said nothing, because rocking the boat felt like betrayal of everything he'd built his life around. Nobody makes a documentary about the staff member who knew, and stayed quiet, and told herself it wasn't her place.
They're not villains — nobody's writing them a downfall arc. They're not victims — nobody's holding a vigil for them either. They're just people, doing the very ordinary thing people do, which is protect the version of reality that lets them keep their life the way it is. And that's exactly why nobody looks at them. And exactly why they're the ones actually worth studying, if you want any of this to stop happening again.
What the Army Is Actually Made Of
Here's what gets lost every time the story becomes only about the leader: one person, however dysfunctional — however grandiose, however good he is at charm and manipulation and making people feel like the exception is him and only him — cannot manufacture thirty years of silence by himself. He needs a board that doesn't ask hard questions, and I mean specific board members, not an abstract “board” — actual people who sat in actual rooms and let actual red flags go by because asking felt disloyal, or awkward, or like more trouble than it was worth. He needs a staff culture where the person who finally does raise a concern loses her job within the year, and everyone watching takes note of that, whether or not anyone ever says it out loud. He needs an institution — meaning, again, real people making real decisions — that decides, without ever formally voting on it, that protecting the reputation matters more than protecting whoever's getting hurt.
Take that army away, and the same leader has almost nowhere to go. That is the entire difference between a leader who gets stopped in year one and a leader who gets away with it for thirty — not because the second leader was worse, but because his army was bigger, or quieter, or better trained to look away.
How This Army Gets Built in Mission Culture
I've watched this particular army assemble itself inside ministry and mission settings more times than I want to count, and it recruits the same way every time. Disagreement gets punished — not with anyone announcing a punishment, just with who gets passed over, who stops getting invited to the real conversations, who eventually finds a reason to leave before anyone has to push them out. Loyalty gets treated as identical to faithfulness, so that questioning the leader starts to feel, physically, like questioning God — which is a very effective way to make sure nobody questions anything. And when something finally does surface, the first instinct in the room is almost never “let's find out what actually happened.” It's “how do we protect the mission” — as if the mission and the man running it were the same thing, which is exactly the confusion that got everyone here in the first place.
None of it requires anyone in that army to be a bad person. That's the part that's hard to sit with. Most of them are building this, one small non-confrontation at a time, because they genuinely believe they're being faithful, or kind, or keeping the peace. That's what makes an army like this so durable and so hard to see from the inside. Nobody there thinks of themselves as enabling anything. They think of themselves as keeping the peace, though a decision to avoid conflict is not actually the same thing.
What It Would Take to Break Up the Army
The fix cannot be simply a smarter way to screen out a bad leader before he's hired — people like this are often unusually good at seeming safe, that's part of how they got this far in the first place. The actual fix is about the army, not the leader: a way for someone to raise a concern that doesn't route through the very leadership the concern is about. Board members who don't owe their seat, their friendships, or their sense of belonging to the leader's continued approval — and who are willing to use whatever independence they've got. A process for handling a serious allegation that gets decided before there's a crisis to test it on, instead of improvised, under pressure, by people who are also trying to protect everything else they care about.
None of that requires suspecting any specific person of anything right now. It just requires believing, ahead of time, that an army like this could form here — which is a far harder thing for a healthy-feeling organization to believe than it sounds like it should be.
If you want the fuller version of this — something concrete enough to actually hand to a board, not just something to nod along with — I've written it up separately: Can Your Board Name It? A Field Guide to High-Stakes Governance Blind Spots.
The leader gets a documentary. The victims get their pain finally taken seriously, which is the least they're owed and usually comes far too late. The army — the board, the staff, the friends, the whole slow machinery of people who let it keep going — gets nothing. No documentary, no reckoning, not even a hard look. And that's exactly backwards, because the leader was never the part anyone could do anything about after the fact. The army is the part that's still sitting in boardrooms right now, in a hundred other organizations, doing the same work of looking away. That's the part worth writing about. That's the part worth fixing.