← Back to resources
FormationFaith

The Role That's Already Taken

Allison Brown

When I opened a medical clinic, I wanted to do it right, which to me meant taking two postures at once: I would run the place, and I would also be a learner. I hired a local doctor and a local nurse to orient me to the customs of their health care system, because I had no business assuming I already knew them, and the plan was to fuse what was familiar and useful to me with what I hoped to bring and improve, honoring what was already good there instead of trampling over it. It was a decent plan, right up until I noticed that nearly every patient who came through the door wanted to be seen by “the white doctor,” which meant me, and almost none of them wanted to be seen by the local doctor.

That felt terrible. And it isn't a story peculiar to my clinic, because it happens anywhere a struggling country has a medical mission presence: there are inundations of visiting “good doctors” from the rich countries who come for a short time, the demand for them is enormous, and it has to be discouraging for a local doctor who wants to serve his own people to watch his own people walk past him for the visitor who will be gone in a week's time.

How It Happens So Easily

I don't think the patients were being foolish or ungrateful; they were just making a beeline to the target they assessed had greater training, resources, and influence. When you live with need as the daily weather, whether that's physical poverty or spiritual poverty or both, and someone arrives from outside with money, training, and access you don't have, you know exactly what that person is capable of doing for you if they only notice you and have compassion. So you try to be noticed, which is what anyone would do, and the foreigner, especially the one who stays for years and not just a week, becomes the gatekeeper without ever deciding to. Now the ones who get noticed get blessed. The ones who don't, don't.

The part that's harder to say is what it does to the person holding the gate. You get used to it — to being the one who can ease someone's pain or solve their problem, and to the gratitude that comes with it — and being used to it slides, very gently, into expecting it, and from there into believing you're the reason things work. It goes to your head. It also tends to grow by displacement: the local leaders who were already doing the day-in, day-out work, and who could often help their own community given half a chance, get replaced in the eyes of the people they serve by the person with the resources, and each time that happens the foreigner's influence and power go up while the local leader's goes down.

The Baptism

I watched a version of this happen in a church, and I'll tell it without any identifying details because the details aren't the point. A missionary traveled a circuit of churches and had become so popular, so desired, that congregants began wanting him to baptize them whenever he came through, even though he had never built a relationship with the person standing in the water. The local pastor, the one who had done all the pouring in and investing with that person, day after day, did not get to share in the moment his investment had earned. Nobody meant any harm by it — the congregation was honoring the one they believed stood closest to power, and the missionary was accepting an invitation — but the one moment that could have honored the pastor's years of work went to someone else.

Three Postures, One Root

I've come to think of a few familiar postures as the attitudes we slip into when we lose track of our role, and I'll admit the shorthand is a little tongue-in-cheek, but it holds up. The savior in us believes it all depends on us, that if we don't rescue this person or this village or this project nobody will, and it feels so much like devotion that we rarely notice it's a weight we were never meant to carry and, just as much, a way of seeing ourselves as more than we are. The hero in us performs the rescue for an audience — donors, the home church, a spouse, or our own inner critic — and I want to be clear that I value acts of courage in other people, and it's the performance I'm taking issue with, not the courage. The cowboy in us rides in alone and unaccountable, sure our instincts are enough, with no need for the wisdom of the community we've come to serve or anyone who's been doing this longer than we have.

Every one of them starts with something good, whether that's compassion, a desire to inspire, or plain initiative, and every one of them goes wrong at the same root. On the surface it's a misunderstanding about our role. Underneath, it's the temptation to see ourselves as more than we are, which is the abolition of humility in service, and it's the reason we start to morph our role at all. Each of these postures ends up ugly and unhelpful for the same reason, which is that they all feed the same place: self-aggrandizement. So here it is, as kindly as I can say it. There is room for one Savior, and the position is filled. There's no such thing as a hero, in the performing sense of the word. And cowboys belong in western movies, not on the mission field.

What I Did About It

Eventually I decided to staff the clinic entirely with local providers and to step back into an administrative role only. What I wanted was for the patients, and the community around them, to grow in their assessment and respect of their own providers instead of discounting them, and I couldn't see how that would happen while the preferred option was the foreigner in the room. We began a major initiative to educate and professionally develop the local providers, and at the same time we worked on improving health education across the community in general.

It didn't go smoothly. Patients resisted, and some stopped coming once the white doctor was no longer there. Americans and locals alike told me that patients would not accept, would not adjust to, and would not learn the new norms and rules we wanted to put in place. Enough people came because their need was real, though, and over time the clinic built a great reputation, because the local providers gave absolutely excellent care — evidence-based, with good outcomes — and people could see it for themselves. We started several initiatives that helped many people and made real improvements in the lives of families on the mountain we served.

The people who said patients would never change were wrong, and it was beautiful to watch the attitude shift. Trust in local provider care rose among the patients, and the providers' satisfaction rose with it, because they were finally receiving the respect I think they had always deserved.

The Good News

Stepping back like that is only possible if you come to realize that the role you're stepping back from was never yours to hold, and that is the good news I most want to say to anyone who serves. There is one Savior, and He holds the burden we've been trying to carry, which means we are not leading the charge. Paul puts it more plainly than I can: he planted, Apollos watered, “but God gave the growth,” and neither the one who plants nor the one who waters is anything on their own (1 Corinthians 3:6–7, ESV). I find that freeing. It doesn't make planting and watering unimportant, since somebody has to do both and do them well, it just puts us in the right place in the story.

And the invitation that goes with it is addressed to the tired. Jesus invites everyone who is weary and carrying heavy burdens to come to him for rest (Matthew 11:28), and I take that to be meant for us in particular, since the surest way to get that tired is to spend years carrying a role that was never ours.

The same passage answers the arrogance, and I think that matters just as much as answering the weight. If neither the one who plants nor the one who waters is anything on their own, then the temptation to see ourselves as more than we are loses its footing, because there is nothing for us to be impressed with and no credit that was ours to take. Humility in service is simply seeing ourselves accurately, as people invited into a work far larger than we are, bringing gifts we didn't produce to a part of the story we didn't write. It's also what makes the small, practical acts possible: handing the baptism back to the pastor who earned it, handing the patient back to the local provider, and letting the people who've been doing the day-in, day-out work keep doing it. We were never the reason anything grows, so we are free to be glad when it does and to go on doing our own part.

Knowing Your Part

Knowing your part takes some honest looking, and a few questions help. What was I actually asked to do, and by whom? What am I carrying that nobody handed me? Who was doing this work here before I arrived, and what would it look like to hand their moment back to them? And who is close enough to tell me the truth when I've crossed from my part into someone else's?

None of this is a demotion, though I understand why it can feel like one at first. The part you were actually given is smaller than the one you've been trying to fill, and the One who holds the work invites us into that small part without ever handing us the responsibility for how it turns out. That leaves us free to do what we were given — to work, to be productive, to take real satisfaction in the work — and then, when the season comes, to retire and rest from it, knowing it goes on in other hands and, underneath all of them, in His. It really is an honor to be a part of the work without having to own it.

I don't know how to encourage anyone better than to point at a feeling most of us already know: doing something hard that is also worthwhile is one of the best feelings in the world. It comes in its purest form once we've put down the part that was never ours, because then the hardness is only the hardness of the work, with no extra weight from imagining we have to carry the outcome. So know your part, do it well, and rest, and enjoy being one of the many hands in work that was never yours to finish.

Work with Un-barred

The lost thing is sought because of its inherent value.

Explore services